Happy Anniversary Cards in Red and Yellow

I

I have two anniversary cards to share. They are both the same except they use different border punches. The label stamps and sentiment stamps are by Hero Arts with red ink by Stampin Up and black ink by Hero Arts. The paper is old and I haven't a clue who it is made by. The border punches are both by Fiskars. I think they both look pretty but do you have a preference?

Thanks for looking.